NY Sports Dog: Bad Jerry Manuel Decision #74

Tuesday, June 2, 2009

Bad Jerry Manuel Decision #74

Wow, these are really piling up now.

Situation: 8th inning, Mets up 5-3, David Wright draws a leadoff walk against a young pitcher, Jeremy Reed up, Wilson Valdez on deck.

What would you do?

What did Jerry Manuel do?

He elected to bunt with Reed, who bunted back to the pitcher, who turned and threw to second to force David Wright.

OK, wait a minute here.

Jerry Manuel had Jeremy Reed bunt to get Wilson Valdez up?

Jeremy Reed is batting .291 and is a career .258 hitter with a .681 OPS...he had two hits on the night...Reed also has a little pop, with 84 extra-base hits in 1,112 career at-bats. He's not great, but amazing when compared to Wilson Valdez.

For his career, Wilson Valdez has a .213 batting average and a .257 OBP with the worst slugging percentage in history--.278...that is not a typo. He has a lifetime OPS of .535 and a total of 13 extra base hits in 263 career at-bats.

All of the statistical studies in the world tell you that you don't bunt the man over after a leadoff walk....that the odds of him scoring decrease dramatically with one out, even if he makes it to second.

Every man alive knows you don't bunt a semi-productive hitter to get to Wilson Valdez. Everyone except Jerry "Goin' with my Gut" Manuel, who falls in love with every scrap heap guy he finds.

So after the promising start to the inning, Jerry bunts, the sacrifice fails, and the Mets went out quietly with nothing to show for DW's leadoff effort.


Reblog this post [with Zemanta]


kranepool society said...

I was stunned he let Livan Hernandez swing away after two bunt atempts that went for strikes. I don't care (Gary Cohen) how good a hitting pitcher Hernandez is I'd much rather he strike out than swing as he did into a double play.

Also why use Parrnell in the 6th and not Stokes and keep Parrnel for the 8th a let Putz take a night off? I don't consider that a second guess as Parnell has shown to be more effective than Putz in that spot. Enough with worring about players feelings

Ravi said...

Kranepool society: Parnell has been a guy that you can bring in with runners on to get out of a jam. It was a critical juncture, with the Bucs down by two and two runners on. Parnell succeeded in a similar situation yesterday. It was also a situation that called for a strikeout (particularly once the bases were loaded), and Bobby has been very good at keeping the ball out of play. At a key moment like that, you want your best guy out there. If the Met bullpen didn't come through in the 6th inning, we wouldn't be talking about Putz at all.

Anyway, with JJ out, the bullpen does stack up nicely, with Bobby in the 8th, and Stokes, Green, and Feliciano ready for the 6th and 7th, if necessary.

Related Posts with Thumbnails